Humanfrog Lab

Fully managed IT, co-managed IT, ad-hoc support or our own team: which model fits us, and how do we choose a good managed service provider?

IT outsourcing is no longer just calling a technician when the printer breaks. Between your own system administrator and occasional outside help there are models that differ sharply in who monitors your systems, who acts during an outage and who is accountable: fully managed IT with a managed service provider (MSP), co-managed IT alongside your own IT person, and ad-hoc support.

The right model depends less on the monthly price than on your situation: how many sites and countries you operate in, how critical your systems are, when you need support and which regulatory obligations apply. The tool on this page recommends a model based on your answers and generates a provider evaluation checklist, red flags and a 30/60/90-day transition plan without downtime.

Which managed IT model fits us, and how do we choose a good managed service provider?

Answer nine questions about your company, sites, people and requirements. You will get a recommended model with its trade-offs, a list of what to keep in-house, a provider checklist weighted by your answers and a transition plan. You can print the result or save it as a PDF.

Nine questions about your company, sites, people and requirements. The result shows which managed IT model fits you and why, what to keep in-house in any case, how to evaluate a managed service provider (MSP) and how to switch provider without downtime.

Question of

Managed IT model: recommendation and MSP selection checklist

Recommended managed IT model

Trade-offs:

How each model matches your answers

The match is an indicative score based on your answers, not a ranking of providers.

Before you ask for an availability percentage, check how much downtime it actually allows: SLA and uptime calculator.

Keep in-house with every model

  • Ownership of all admin accounts, passwords, domains, licences and cloud tenants in the company's name, with emergency access that you hold yourself.
  • Documentation of the environment: asset inventory, network diagrams, configurations and procedures, kept up to date by the partner.
  • Decisions on priorities, budget, risks and access.
  • Responsibility for compliance (NIS2, GDPR, sector rules), which cannot be transferred to a supplier.

Checklist for evaluating a managed service provider

Priorities are weighted by your answers. Ask every shortlisted provider the same questions and ask for evidence, not promises.

Red flags

  • The provider wants to register admin accounts or cloud tenants in its own name.
  • The SLA only defines a response time and says nothing about resolution time.
  • There is no written documentation of the environment, or the provider will not hand it over.
  • Vague answers about backups: when was a restore last tested?
  • On-site work in other countries is "by arrangement", with no named contractor.
  • The contract has no exit clause, or the handover at the end is billed extra with no cap.
  • A low price is quoted before anyone has inventoried the environment.

30/60/90-day transition plan without downtime

Moving to a new provider, or from an informal setup to managed IT, should happen in phases, with an overlap and no single "big switch" day.

  1. Days 1–30: Inventory of equipment, users, licences, contracts and admin access. All credentials taken over in the company's name, monitoring and security tools deployed, backups verified with a test restore. The previous provider or colleague remains active.
  2. Days 31–60: The new provider takes over user support and monitoring. The most urgent security gaps are closed (MFA, patches, outdated equipment), documentation is completed, and the first monthly SLA review sets the baseline.
  3. Days 61–90: Old access and tools are removed, the recovery plan is tested, the responsibility matrix is confirmed and an improvement roadmap for the next year is agreed. Only now does the previous provider's engagement end.

This tool does not compare costs. Calculate the annual cost of an in-house team, an external partner and a hybrid with the managed IT services cost calculator.

The result is an indicative recommendation based on your answers. It is not legal advice and does not replace a review of contracts, regulatory obligations and your IT environment.

Send yourself the result and talk to an expert ↓

The calculation runs in your browser. Your answers are only sent if you submit the contact form below.

Four models of IT outsourcing

"IT outsourcing" can mean very different arrangements. They differ mainly in who monitors your systems, who acts during an outage and who is accountable for the result:

ModelWho monitors systemsWho acts during an outageTypical use
Fully managed IT (MSP)The provider, continuouslyThe provider, under the SLACompanies without IT staff that need reliable operations
Co-managed ITThe provider and your IT personWhoever the responsibility matrix namesCompanies with one system administrator or a small team
Ad-hoc support (break-fix)NobodyA technician, when availableVery small, non-critical cloud environments
In-house IT teamYour employeesYour employees, when availableLarger companies with a lot of specific on-site work

No model is best for everyone. The key difference is between proactive and reactive work. A managed service provider is paid to keep systems running; a break-fix technician is paid to repair them once they stop. With the first, preventing problems is in the provider's interest. With the second, it is not.

What decides the right model

  • Sites and countries. One office with a cloud environment is a very different job from warehouses and branches in several countries, where the network and identities must be managed as one and someone has to turn up on site.
  • Criticality and support hours. If production or logistics stops during an outage, you need continuous monitoring, guaranteed resolution times and clear out-of-hours coverage. Ad-hoc support does not provide that.
  • Your own people. Without IT staff, fully managed IT is usually the right choice. With a single system administrator, the biggest risk is dependence on one person, so co-managed IT works well: your colleague stays and the partner adds depth, security and cover.
  • Regulation. Entities under NIS2, financial firms under DORA and anyone processing large volumes of personal data need a provider that can demonstrate its security measures and put them into the contract.

Compare the cost of each model separately with the managed IT services cost calculator. This guide focuses on choosing the model and judging the quality of the provider.

What a good managed service provider delivers

Judge providers on evidence, not promises. These are the questions to ask an MSP:

  • An SLA with response and resolution times. A response time only tells you when someone picks up. What matters is how quickly the problem is fixed, by priority and with clear consequences when targets are missed. Before you ask for an availability percentage, use the SLA and uptime calculator to see how much downtime it actually allows.
  • A security baseline as standard. MFA for all accounts, EDR on devices and servers, regular patching, backups with regular restore tests and continuous monitoring. Ask when a restore was last tested.
  • Reporting. A monthly review of tickets, SLA performance, patch status and recommendations shows whether the provider really manages your environment.
  • Escalation and expertise. A named contact, a technical lead and partnerships with the vendors you use, such as Microsoft and Fortinet.

Cybersecurity is not just a technical topic but a management responsibility. A good partner helps you understand risks and decide on them, not just install tools. The same applies to new technology: before you roll out AI tools, have the partner review access rights, data and security, because such tools can see everything a user has access to.

Ownership, the IT support contract and regulation

The most common mistake in IT outsourcing is losing control of your own environment. Admin accounts, passwords, domains, licences and cloud tenants must be in your company's name, and you must hold the emergency access yourself. The documentation of the environment (asset inventory, network diagrams, configurations) must be available to you at all times, not only when the contract ends.

An MSP has access to e-mail, files and systems containing personal data, so under the GDPR it acts as a processor. The data processing agreement under Article 28 GDPR must, among other things, state that the provider engages further processors only with your written authorisation and that, at your choice, it returns or deletes the data when the services end.

The NIS2 Directive (EU) 2022/2555 lists supply chain security, including the relationships with direct suppliers and service providers, among the required risk-management measures, and expects entities to consider the quality of their suppliers' cybersecurity practices. The directive notes that managed security service providers have themselves been targets of cyberattacks and, because they are closely integrated into their customers' operations, pose a particular risk, so it calls for increased diligence when selecting one. It also lists managed service providers as a sector of high criticality (Annex I), so medium-sized and large providers usually fall under NIS2 themselves.

The IT support contract should also cover the scope and what is billed separately, the notice period, an exit plan and the provider's obligation to support the transition to another provider.

Sites in several countries

For companies with sites in Slovenia, Croatia, Serbia and elsewhere in the Balkans, the key question is who will turn up when a switch fails in the warehouse. Ask for named contractors in each country, support in the local language and unified management of the network and identities from one point.

Humanfrog, for example, maintains the network of a company with sites in every Balkan country: its Fortinet network with SD-WAN is connected to a central point we manage, so monitoring, security policies and changes are consistent across all sites. For the logistics company Alfa SP, which operates in Slovenia, Croatia and Serbia, we have managed the IT environment for five years, with 40 active users at six sites: we moved e-mail and documents to Microsoft 365, set up access management, automated backups and central monitoring, and migrated the servers to the cloud.

If you are opening a subsidiary in another Balkan country, also read the guide to IT for Balkan subsidiaries.

Switching IT provider without downtime

If you are unhappy with your current provider, do not terminate the contract until you have an inventory of the environment, all admin credentials and the documentation. Plan the switch within the notice period, with an overlap:

  • Days 1–30: inventory, access taken over in the company's name, monitoring tools deployed and a test restore from backup.
  • Days 31–60: the new provider takes over user support and monitoring and closes the most urgent security gaps.
  • Days 61–90: old access removed, recovery plan tested, responsibility matrix confirmed. Only then does the previous provider's engagement end.

Red flags when choosing: the provider wants accounts registered in its own name, the SLA says nothing about resolution time, there is no documentation, on-site work in other countries is "by arrangement", or a low price is quoted before anyone knows your environment.

The tool above generates a recommendation, a weighted checklist and a transition plan for your situation. If you would like to review your IT environment and the right managed IT model with an expert, talk to us.

Frequently asked questions

What is a managed service provider?
A managed service provider (MSP) is a company that continuously manages, monitors and maintains your IT environment: user devices, servers, cloud, network, security and backups. Unlike a technician you call when something breaks, an MSP prevents problems through monitoring and maintenance, under terms set out in a contract and an SLA.
What is co-managed IT?
Co-managed IT means your own system administrator or IT team stays in place and a partner takes over monitoring, security, servers, out-of-hours coverage and cover for absences. It suits companies with one IT person or a small team that need more depth and continuity without replacing their own people.
What should an IT support contract include?
An IT support contract should define the scope, priorities, response and resolution times for each priority, coverage hours, how tickets are raised, reporting and consequences when targets are missed. It should also state that admin accounts and documentation belong to you, and set out the notice period, exit plan and return of data.
What questions should we ask an MSP?
Ask what the SLA guarantees for resolution, not just response; who acts at night and on public holidays; how on-site work is delivered in each of your countries; which security baseline is standard; in whose name admin accounts are held; how a restore was last tested; and what happens to your data and documentation when the contract ends.
How do we switch IT provider without downtime?
Secure an inventory of the environment, all admin credentials and the documentation before you terminate the contract. Then switch in phases within the notice period so the providers overlap for a few weeks: first access and monitoring, then user support, and finally removal of old access.
Does NIS2 affect the choice of a managed service provider?
Yes. Entities under NIS2 must manage supply chain security, and an MSP has direct access to their systems. The directive also lists managed service providers as a sector of high criticality, so medium-sized and large providers usually fall under NIS2 themselves.

Stay up to date

Regulations, licence prices and technology change fast. When we update the guides and tools in the Lab or publish a new article, we let you know by e-mail. Occasional, and never spam.

Subscribe to the newsletter